How Trump’s false claim about African American support happened
President Trump recently bragged about his support among African Americans, saying his poll numbers had “doubled.” His claim has been repeated thousands of times on TV and online. Some media figures have treated it as fact.
But it’s not. The news organization responsible for the poll, Reuters, says its data is being misconstrued.
Here’s the story of how it happened — showing how right-wing web sites, Trump supporters on social media, and the president spread misleading information so easily.
This matters because Trump supporters were left with the impression that the president is gaining support from African Americans, an idea that is not backed up by data.
On May 2, The Daily Caller published a story titled “Black Male Approval For Trump Doubles In One Week.” This was two days before Trump brought up the subject at the NRA’s annual convention.
The Daily Caller cited Reuters/Ipsos polling. On April 22, the weekly tracking poll had “Trump’s approval rating among black men at 11 percent, while the same poll on April 29, 2018, pegged the approval rating at 22 percent.”
The story pointed out that “Reuters only sampled slightly under 200 black males each week.” But it didn’t explain why that would matter when interpreting the results. And in any case, that nuance was quickly lost as the headline was shared tens of thousands of times on social media.
African American support for Trump has been low ever since he started campaigning. So this notion a sudden surge in support was enticing to pro-Trump commentators.
Charlie Kirk of Turning Point USA copy and pasted part of The Daily Caller story and tweeted, “The defection from the Democrat party is happening and they are moving to Trump.”
The buzz continued on May 3. Liz Wheeler, a host on a small conservative cable channel called OANN, asked if the supposed bump in support was “the Kanye effect.”
Normally you wouldn’t be reading about the poll here, because the Reuters/Ipsos tracking poll does not meet CNN’s standards for reporting.
CNN’s director of polling and election analytics Jennifer Agiesta explained why: “It was conducted using a non-probability online sample, meaning that those who participated signed up to take the poll rather than being randomly selected.” Bottom line: This means “there could be bias in the sample.”
There’s no way to know for sure, but it’s possible that a group of people who freely sign up for a survey are different from a group that is contacted by a pollster.
Nevertheless, the president had found a poll he liked. He brought up the poll in a May 4 speech — shown live on CNN and all the other cable channels — so I think it deserves scrutiny.
In the speech, he thanked Kanye West, the rapper who recently provoked outrage by promoting Trump.
“Kanye West must have some power,” he said, “because you probably saw I doubled my African American poll numbers. We went from 11 to 22 in one week. Thank you, Kanye. Thank you.”
There are a couple things to notice about that quote. First, the remark that his audience “probably saw” the poll. Yes, the claim had ricocheted its way around the pro-Trump echo chamber, but it wasn’t common knowledge. It wasn’t a story on the nightly news. Still, Trump figured NRA conventioneers and TV viewers already knew.
Second, Trump asserted that his support “doubled” among African Americans. Even taking the tracking poll at face value, which would be a mistake to do, Trump got it wrong. The Daily Caller story cited a jump from 11% to 22% among black men, not men and women combined.
It’s unclear how Trump came across the Reuters data.
At the NRA convention, Trump continued: “When I saw the number, I said, ‘That must be a mistake. How can that have happened?’ Even the pollsters thought that must be a mistake.”
Actually, yes. But it wasn’t a mistake in the way Trump meant. Chris Kahn, the U.S. political polling editor for Reuters, said in an email on Saturday that the 11% and 22% data points were misunderstood.
“The sample sizes for those two measurements were too small to reliably suggest any shift in public opinion,” Kahn told CNNMoney through a spokeswoman.
This is common sense: The more narrowly you slice the data, the less reliable it becomes. Reuters and Ipsos survey about 350 people a day, 11,000 a month, on the internet. The outlets call the relative precision of the results as a “credibility interval.”
In this case, the president’s approval rating among black men, “the credibility interval was more than +/- 9 percentage points for each measurement, which leaves open the possibility that his approval also could have dropped in this time frame,” Kahn said.
It could have dropped!
This is why the president’s words require constant and close examination. It’s risky, even irresponsible, to just quote someone without fact-checking the content — particularly when the person has a track record like Trump’s.
Looking closely at this case, we can see how it happens — how faulty info gets the White House’s thumbs up. First, a website posted a story that was incomplete at best, misleading at worst; then the claim went viral; and someone showed it to the president.
Did anyone in the administration check it out? Did anyone warn the president that the stat was faulty? Maybe, maybe not. Either way, the president still went ahead and read it aloud in a nationally televised speech. He further misstated what the poll actually said.
The presidential sound bite gave even more oxygen to the shaky claim. Hosts on Fox brought it up on Saturday and Sunday without correcting it. The idea continued to spread.
And all of this was based on a tiny sliver of an online survey — that even the pollster says was misinterpreted.
So what about the polls that do meet CNN’s standards? Those polls do not show approval ratings that are as high or that suggest they “are shifting meaningfully in Trump’s direction,” Agiesta said.
“Gallup’s latest tracking data among black respondents finds 13% of African Americans approving of Trump,” she said. (That’s an average for all of April.)
A Pew Research Center survey from late April also shows Trump’s approval rating at 13%. And a Quinnipiac University poll from a few days earlier in April showed 14% approval.
“West is an influential artist, but there is no proof that black men’s views of Trump are shaped significantly — or at all — by the rapper,” the Washington Post’s Eugene Scott wrote Saturday.
Brian Stelter, CNN