Convicted killer pleads guilty to Jefferson County murders

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

HILLSBORO, MO – It was a stunning moment in a Jefferson County courtroom Wednesday afternoon. A notorious, mass-killer admitted his guilt, then took a knee and apologizes in tears.
Even the most seasoned courthouse workers have never seen anything like it. 38-year-old Nicholas Sheley, pleaded guilty to avoid the death penalty for 2 murders in Festus; part of a 4-day, 8 murder rampage in Missouri and Illinois in 2008. His victims ranged in age from 2 to 93.

“Not a day goes by that I don`t wish I could bring you all back” Sheley said sobbing. “Not a single one of you deserved to die by my hand”, he said he`d felt God`s grace and mercy come over him in prison.
Sheley was here for two murders in Festus. A prosecutor laid out the extensive gruesome evidence that he

Sheley bludgeoned Tom and Jill Estes of Arkansas to death, repeatedly fracturing their skulls then dumping their bodies behind a Festus convenience store. They`d just been to a family graduation party in Florissant.

The prosecution then accepted Sheley`s guilty plea. The victims` loved ones from the Illinois cases were also at the hearing, all hoping for the death penalty and giving Sheley`s surprise apology little credence.

The other six murders were in Illinois, where there is no death penalty. The prosecutor took no questions from reporters or the victims` families about why he`s not pursuing such a strong death penalty case.